Language beauty contest

According to Eurolang, Estonia’s Education Minister is planning to hold a language beauty contest to mark the 90th birthday of the Republic of Estonia. The minister would like school children around the world to make recordings of up to seven words in their languages. The article doesn’t mention who will be judging the entrants or how they’ll go about it.

Have you heard of anything like this before?

Comments (16)

DanielJanuary 10th, 2008 at 7:34 pm

I think we can count out most Germanic languages. Probably a Romance (coincidence?) Language will win!

BobbyJanuary 10th, 2008 at 9:54 pm

I don’t know I have an affinity for Finnish.

ColmJanuary 10th, 2008 at 10:10 pm

I first heard about it when my girlfriend mentioned to me about an old Estonian folk tale that told of a language beauty contest where Italian came first and Estonian came second with the phrase:

“Sõida tasa üle silla” – Drive carefully over the bridge. :-)

I wish I knew what the Italian phrase was!

Chinook McGuckJanuary 10th, 2008 at 11:33 pm

Actually, it’s quite possible that a celtic language will win. I wouldn’t be surprised if Persian were to be high up there too.

luningningJanuary 10th, 2008 at 11:35 pm

still, french has a high rating, based on how many people love the way it sounds

Joe DeRoseJanuary 11th, 2008 at 12:07 am

It’s interesting to me how languages sound to people who don’t speak them. I once read an article quoting a Chinese woman who said that before she learned English, it sounded to her like a “pit of hissing snakes.” As a native speaker, I had never thought about it – but with the frequency of “s,” “sh,” and “th” sounds in English, I can see the point.

ARJanuary 11th, 2008 at 1:05 am

Definitely not a Dravidian language, unless you think “asjherauihscehrajfdjasdfhalueyraklsjdhfajqoewxklnqehahr rrrrrrrrr” sounds pretty.
Maybe Portuguese or Burmese. I always liked Burmese because it has a musical, sing-song quality to it thats very pleasing.

jakeJanuary 11th, 2008 at 3:18 am

I find it interesting that there should be a contest about linguistic Aesthetics, which is primarily about preference. Essentially, its about what the judges prefer, not about the platonic idea of true beauty. But no matter, it should be fun. I myself prefer the Gaelic and Germanic tongues. I heard a Cornish song (Ellas Mari) and it had a delicate beauty about it.
Germanic languages have a noble beauty to them.

Sion, AberystwythJanuary 11th, 2008 at 4:09 pm

I’d much prefere German or Dutch to French. French just seems to be too much fuss, whilst German or Dutch (or Welsh of course!) seem a nice balance of consonants and vowels and all round much more honest languages. You can hear where words start and finish.

JoeRose raises an interesting point about how languages sound to non-speakers. My daughter (6 and 4) are monoglot Welsh-speakers at the moment and when they impersonate English it’s a language with no consonants and full of dipthonged ‘o’ and ‘a’ – ‘ow’ and ‘ei’ sound to Welsh-speakers. They speak something like; ‘ow ei ow, ei ow ei ow?’

They also categorise English speakers as people who say ‘hello’ (or ‘helow’ to their Welsh ears) and ‘helo’ (rounded ‘o’) for Welsh-speakers that’s how they know which language a person speaks.

They’ve also noticed that ‘pobl Saesneg yn dweud bai bai a pobl Cymraeg yn dweud tara’ (English people say bye bye and Welsh people say tara) for goodbye.

Giovanni 'Prestige'January 11th, 2008 at 4:38 pm

Colm:
> “Sõida tasa üle silla” – Drive carefully over the bridge. :-)
> I wish I knew what the Italian phrase was!

Ask and you shall be given. :) A possible translation is [i]guidare con prudenza sul ponte[/i] (/gwi’dare koɱpru’dEntsa sul’ponte/).

MirandaJanuary 13th, 2008 at 4:05 am

french is such a beautiful language, and the only one i’m even close to fluent in, but i LOVE the way finnish sounds. i’d be down for an african language taking the prize too, for all their fun clicks and other unique sounds.
will you post more information about this if you get it? i’d absolutely LOVE to hear all the entries.

NasJanuary 13th, 2008 at 4:39 pm

I am pretty sure that russian won’t win ))

Armine AbrahamyanJanuary 14th, 2008 at 2:15 pm

I don’t think that 7 words can show beauty of a language!

-armine

RuralityJanuary 19th, 2008 at 2:10 am

Sounds more like a job for Omniglot to me!

I agree though – seven words is way too few.

JamesJanuary 20th, 2008 at 9:49 pm

Brazilian portuguese should win, or possibly highland latin american spanish (my favorite is Guatemala at the moment… I was listening to a report of the death of Bobby FIsher on Emisoras Unidas and the way the man said “ajedrez” and “ajedrecista” made me happy for hours).

I suggest the chileans don´t make an entry unless they are going to bribe the judges with a lot of Chilean wine.

WeiliFebruary 7th, 2008 at 12:07 am

Might as well have a color beauty contest.