dtp883 wrote:Delodephius wrote:Most people think Turkish, Arabic and Iranian are the same.
Wait, they aren't related?! I thought they were like Swedish, Danish, and Norwegian.
dtp883 wrote:Well I know Korean is not as close as Japanese and Chinese are.
I wouldn't call it nonexistent just because it's analytic. I always thought of such languages as having simpler morphology (or in the case of Chinese, none) and more complex syntax. A language like Latin has complicated inflectional paradigms but virtually free word order.Sobekhotep wrote:Japanese and Korean are a hell of a lot more similar to each other than either is to Chinese. They both have similar grammar, while Chinese grammar is way different, borderline nonexistent, in my opinion.
I'm skeptical. The Uralic and Altaic families were once thought to be related due to similar structural features (SOV word order, agglutination, vowel harmony) and it was found those resemblances were areal, not genetic. I suspect it's the same for Japanese and Korean which have been spoken in the same area long enough for a sprachbund to develop.Some scholars actually classify the Japonic & Korean languages under Altaic, but this is not widely accepted. Korean classification is still ongoing, though, & it may end up in the Altaic group after all.
Talib wrote:The Uralic and Altaic families were once thought to be related due to similar structural features (SOV word order, agglutination, vowel harmony)
Talib wrote:SOV word order is an argument for a relation between Japanese and Altaic, though.
The current consensus is that the Uralic and Altaic families are not related and any similarities between them are due to geographic proximity, not genetic relation; and Japanese and Korean may be Altaic (or at least related to each other somehow) but this is extremely controversial when the unity of the Altaic family itself has been called into question.dtp883 wrote:I knew Japanese was thought of possibly being Altaic. I've never really read about Korean though. I think I remeber reading about a Altaic-Uralic connection and thinking how strange that Finnish and Japanese could be related. I haven't been able to find any information on this in a long time though.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests